It was with great interest that I read a post on Active Rain by Ken Cash of Incline Village, Nevada. He poses the question of rent v. own - a question Realtors regularly face in this market.
This past week, I had the usual buyer who says, ‘why buy? Shouldn’t I just rent? After all look at the costs of owning. Sure the interest rates are low, yes I have good credit and can qualify. Yep, I have 40+% for the down. But why? I mean look at the costs. I am going to pay $3000 month in payments, the taxes are $19,000 a year, the homeowners association is $385 a month. OK, I have $60,000 in deductions. So what? I can rent this same place for $2000 a month.”
After seeing property taxes of $19,000 per year and knowing my own are under $1500, I think I’d definitely rent, too!
There’s a web site that I won’t say the name of here (not so G-rated name), but it touches on some of the myths of home ownership that are valid. For example, the writer says it’s a myth to think that when you buy you build equity through forced savings of paying your mortgage.
ABSOLUTELY NOT! That is exactly what home equity lines and continuous refinancings were all about. Spending your savings as opposed to accumulating it and making yourself a “renter with an option to eventually own”. A person very close to me has just refinanced a 30 year mortgage after 21 years effectively turning it into a 51 year mortgage and unless the almighty intervenes they won’t be paying it off in this life.
I have refinanced my home about two or three years ago and very much regret it. It was when home values were climbing like crazy, so we thought we suddenly had $40,000 in equity after just two and a half years. We refinanced and paid off credit cards, two cars, and consolidated our 80:20 mortgage into one mortgage. Now if we want to sell, we’re in upside down because our home is worth only about $20,000 more than when we first bought because of dropping home values. We plan to ride it out, though. Or see if our bank can do a refinance at its current value.
Welcome to the reality of the popped housing bubble.