Weak Outlook On Investment Income Could Spur Higher Rates
The insurance industry is faced with the outlook of declining investment income for the foreseeable future with the economy in it’s current state. The industry’s losses due to the collapse of the subprime mortgage market is expected to eventually surpass the claims paid out for Hurricane Katrina.
What most people don’t realize is that a large percentage of the industry’s profits are derived from investment income rather than insurance premiums. For the most part, insurance companies tend to price policies to closely match what they expect to pay out in claims. They usually do this in an attempt to gain market share.
Now, it doesn’t take a genius to figure out that companies aren’t around to just break even. Most companies will have a target rate for Return On Equity(ROE) that they wish to achieve. But with investment income declining something has to give.
Even in relatively good times for the industry, they are usually involved in a number of disputes with state regulators over insurance rates. I’d say you can expect some bitter fighting later this year when companies submit their next annual rate proposals.
Many states make it illegal for companies to raise rates to make up for a previous year’s investment losses. However, companies do submit estimates on their projected investment income when they file rate proposals. With those projections expected to fall, there will be a growing pressure for insurance companies to raise rates to compensate.
Losses from the subprime mortgage collapse are finally catching up to the insurance industry.
When Wellpoint Inc., the nation’s largest health insurer by membership, unexpectedly cut it’s earnings forecast for 2008, it sent ripples through the entire industry. The stock fell by as much as 29% in trading Tuesday and it’s rivals didn’t fare much better.